From Magic City Morning Star

R.P. BenDedek
Are Americans Welcome in China?
By R.P. BenDedek
Feb 22, 2006 - 9:49:00 AM

WuQuan countryside in Hong Hu
At the end of December I wrote an article here at Magic City called: "The Pompous and Arrogant R.P.BenDedek."

Recently an American Friend wrote me stating that after reading that article, she was a little concerned at how she would be received in China, given that she is American.

Her concerns came from the following points which I made in that article.

  • Your words 'sound' like you are a bleeding heart apologist, which 'sounds' to me like you would be one of those who constantly condemns your own country, apologising for everything it says [and does]. So let's just get this straight in the context of the student who wants to kill George Bush. While most Chinese young people freely admit that they like all the benefits that Western (read American) civilization has brought them, 'They live to see the U.S.A. DESTROYED'.

Quotes from Chinese students:

  • Americans are imperialists who must be stopped.
  • Americans want to control the world.
  • Americans make slaves of the people of the world.
  • Americans want to conquer China.
  • America is trying to get Taiwan and China to fight.
  • America interferes in every country.
  • I want to kill all Americans.
  • I can't wait till China is Strong so that we can crush America.
  • Death to America. - here is the best [from a 37 year old friend] -
  • "You know that we Chinese are friendly people, and many of us have American friends, and we all like everything American, but in our heart of hearts, we hate America and what it stands for and we hope one day to crush it�.

This is a copy of my friends' email:

WuQuan
Oh wow. Dare I, as an American, even try to engage in a relationship with Chinese people ? Will I always be seen as described? Is it possible that after meeting me they would see a difference between political America and an American person with a big heart? Will I have to hate my own country to make any progress as a Chinese friend? These are many of the issues in Foreign Babes in China. Believe it or not, I'm completely FASCINATED by these questions. I just hope I have a thick enough skin to deal with the answers. I'm so glad I "know" you.

This now, was my reply:

YiChang
If you want to walk the 'fear track' try this one on for size.

With the 3 boys in my household, I went to Chibi across the river to show them the museum park. While we were looking for the buddhist temple, the boys became a little perturbed and kept hurrying me on. I thought nothing of it at the time, but one later told me that one of the villagers had said: 'The last time foreigners came here they (the Japanese) killed a lot of people. Maybe we should kill THIS foreigner!'.

As a 'joker' I could see the funny side, and wondered if the whole purpose of saying it wasn't to actually scare the life out of the kids.

Anyway.... to answer your questions - DON'T WORRY! IT IS NORMAL!

There have been students who were really obnoxious..... and you just know they have these thoughts in their heads (about Americans) and since I am white - I'm obviously American. I like to stir the locals when they point and call me a foreigner. One day I was walking down a narrow pathway and two boys were headed toward me in deep discussion. I knew that they would soon look up, and I knew one would utter 'Laowai' - foreigner. I always say something back in Chinese.... spin around as if searching and then ask 'Where' I see no foreigner.... etc etc etc but on this occasion, what came out of the boys mouth was 'Meiguodi' - American!

I not only shocked them, and everyone else within earshot, but myself as well, for I automatically in Chinese shouted (S-H-O-U-T-E-D) I'm not American! I'm Australian!

Anyway, no worries. You will be accepted as you are, as a person. The Chinese are racist, but not in the western NASTY way (usually).

HongHu
I cannot tell how Americans feel - when negativity flows, but I do know that a smile or a nod goes a long long long long way. My latest story about Chengdu at Magic City tells of my behaviour toward two small boys, and while westerners may find it strange, the Chinese love the attention, the humour, and the friendliness.

Be happy, be genuine, be humourous, be kind, be happy, be friendly, be happy, and finally be happy and humourous and everyone will love you.

The Chinese can be very arrogant - but it is an arrogance that derives from a feeling of inferiority. I could explain this with examples at length..... so if there is one thing likely to put a chinese person off, it will be anything that they see as a superiority complex.

Be happy, friendly and humourous - do not turn your nose up at anything you see no matter how you react on the inside. This is a Chinese custom. Honour everyone as you want to be honoured. Simple really.

Do you feel better?

Teacher Judy on the left, and Harry Potter on the right

So there! Being an American in China is not like being an American in Palestine, or a foreigner in any Islamic country currently held in the sway of offense at the Danish Cartoons. Maybe they don't like your country, or your politics, or feel economically inferior, but the Chinese will usually stick to custom and honour you as a guest.

And should they be disinclined to do so, they are nevertheless well aware of Chinese Law, which treats very severely those who make trouble for foreigners.

R.P.Bendedek

Email: rpbendedek@hotmail.com


R.P.BenDedek is the pseudonym of the Author of 'The King's Calendar: The Secret of Qumran' (www.kingscalendar.com), and is a guest columnist at Magic City Morning Star News. An Australian, he currently teaches Conversational English in China.

Photographic Stories from China<

The King's Calendar' is a synchronous chronological presentation of the history of Ancient Israel, as principally recorded in the Biblical books of Kings and Chronicles, and sets forth Apologetics for and the results of R.P.BenDedek's discovery of an "artificial chronological scheme" running through the Books of the Bible, Josephus,the Damascus Documents of the Dead Sea Scrolls, and Seder Olam Rabbah. www.kingscalendar.com.



© Copyright 2002-2008 by Magic City Morning Star