Magic City Morning Star

Advertising | RSS Feed | About Us 

Last Updated: Sep 10, 2014 - 2:08:00 AM 

An eclectic mix of news and information
Staff Login
Donate towards our web hosting bill!

Front Page 
  -- Local
  -- State
  -- National
  -- IRS News
  -- Win at Work
  -- History
  Tech Notes
  -- Comics
  -- R.P. BenDedek
  -- Kenneth Tellis
  -- M Stevens-David
  -- Down the Road
  Today in History
  -- Editor's Desk
  -- Guest Column
  -- Scheme of Things
  -- Michael Devolin
  -- Tom DeWeese
  -- Ed Feulner
  -- Jim Kouri
  -- Julie Smithson
  -- J. Grant Swank
  -- Doug Wrenn
  Agenda 21
  Book Reviews
  -- Old Embers

Web Directory Reviews
WDR Directory of Directories
Restore The Republic - The Home of the Freedom Movement!

Book Reviews

R.P. BenDedek Book Review: "Joseph of Arimathea" by Brian Mellor
By R.P. BenDedek
Feb 26, 2014 - 6:40:21 AM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

At over 400 pages involving 50 Chapters "Joseph of Arimathea" by Brian Mellor was for me way too long and far too drawn out, which is a pity, because it is a really good story. By the time I reached chapter 10 I was impatient for the real story to begin and I began speed reading until I got to about chapter 20.

If I am going to review a book, I feel it only right to read it all and in doing so I make notes. Those notes provide me with specific reference points for comments that might be made in my review. In my notes on chapter 19 of this book, I wrote: "The story is too long -- too dragged out..." and at chapter 26 I wrote:

"The pace picks up leading up to the crucifixion -- the writing is good -- the description good -- it is all moving along nicely... all too late... people will become bored before this..."

Another criticism I have is that the author spent too much time sermonizing, by which I mean that the long drawn out monologues were obviously the author speaking and not the character. The author may speak through the character but in this case I felt that the character was merely a very thin mask for the author.

At chapters 4,7,9, 10 and 18 my notes read: 'Sermonizing." At chapters 7 and 10 I actually wrote 'filler,' meaning that I wondered why it took the author a whole chapter to make the points made.

As I have stated however, the storyline is actually good. It is inventive and more importantly, plausible. The author's storytelling comes to the fore from the time of Jesus arrest to the time of his 'resurrection' and for a little time afterward.

There is some humor included in the storyline, such as that involved in the discussion of the small problem suffered by Joseph of 'Jesus Mary and Joseph' fame, the irony involved in the resurrection of Lazarus and of course Jesus' trip in Egypt.

The author's knowledge and understanding of the ancient world, its politics, religions and cultures is both obvious and extensive and I am not ashamed to state that I recorded a list of words/topics contained in the book which I later researched. How many of us know that 'Allah,' the Islamic name of God, actually precedes Islam by hundreds of years, as does also the name 'Saracen?' Who knew that Glastonbury in England held such a prominent place in early Christian mythology.

While the author's biographical detail makes no mention of it, it seems obvious that he is a scholar. His is an interesting and plausible tale, even if it is from the perspective of a "true" believer, a blasphemous one. The book however could have been written in only 30 chapters and literary devices could have been used to make the sermonizing less obvious.

'Josephus of Arimathea' is a self-published book via Trafford Publishing at  and I personally feel that the author would have benefitted by opting for their "Advanced Editorial" service. It seems obvious by some of the spelling and paragraph spacing errors in the latter part of my PDF version of the book, that this service was not purchased.*

10/10 for the storyline, 8/10 for (general) writing, but 5/10 for overall effect. Sorry about that!

Would I recommend this book to others? You bet! If you have the time and inclination to read an interesting historical fiction then by all means buy this book, although cost wise I think that the nook book price is most appropriate.

R.P. BenDedek

* Trafford publishing normal editorial services are limited by the service you buy and the word length of the book.

"Joseph of Arimathea"
by Brian Mellor
ISBN-13: 9781466953956
Publisher: Trafford Publishing
Publication date: 8/22/2012
Pages: 456

© Copyright 2002-2014 by Magic City Morning Star

Top of Page

Book Reviews
Latest Headlines
Milt Gross Book Review: "The Devil Wins" by Reed Farrel Coleman for the late Robert Parker
Martha Stevens-David Review: "White Ashes" by John D. Moulton
Milt Gross Book Review: "A" is for Alibi by Sue Grafton
Milt Gross Book Review: "Night and Day" by the late Robert Parker
Milt Gross Book Review: "The Bazaar of Bad Dreams" by Stephen King

A Dinosaur of Education - a blog by James Fabiano.
Shobe Studios
Wysong Foods - Pets and People Too